5 Jun 2013

Analysis of the Character of Birling in An Inspector Calls with Quotes


Character Summary
Arthur Birling is the first character who speaks in An Inspector Calls. He is he first to be investigated or accused by the Inspector and is the first to be mentioned in the stage directions [a prosperous manufacturer].

In Birling, Priestly has created a character who tends to dominate the action wherever he can. As the patriarch of a prosperous family, and owner of a factory, Birling's job is to be in charge. 

Within the play, his role is to have his certainties - about the Titanic, Germany*, personal and social responsibility - destroyed. He resists Goole, shifts blame, and is delighted when he thinks it was a hoax. Birling represents those of us who do not want to learn the hard lesson.

Social and Historical Context
*Priestley wrote the play in 1945. It is set in 1912, the Edwardian period, just before the outbreak of World War One.

Why do this?
1. For dramatic irony: Priestley can easily make Birling look stupid by having him say things that we - with the benefit of hindsight - know to be false, about the "unsinkable, absolutely unsinkable" Titanic, "silly little war scares", war is "impossible" "nonsense" and there will be no more "Capital versus labour agitations".

2. The Edwardian age was a golden age of Capitalist prosperity, before the war destroyed everything, and it is this complacent mind-set that Priestley wants to criticise. Birling represents a section of society that thought it was indestructible - at the peak of a Capitalist frenzy. Priestley was anxious that the lessons of the mid-century should be learned.

Birling says "it's a very good time - and soon it'll be an even better time... of peace and prosperity and rapid progress everywhere"

Is This Still Relevant Today?
Sweat shop shoes made by eight-year olds in India, anyone? 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami and crop failure from climate change caused by rampant consumption? It's easy to laugh at Birling. But when you're living well, it's hard to take a hit for the benefit of people whose lives never touch your own.

First Impressions
[a prosperous manufacturerThe house: [substantial and heavily comfortable but not cosy and homelike]; Birling: [a heavy-looking, rather portentious man' 'fairly easy manners, but provincial [i.e. common] in his speech]  Notice that the semantic field of 'weight' is also used for the Inspector.

Key Facts
  • He's wealthy, not aristocratic, unlike his wife. He's highly conscious of social status. He says he has a "good chance of a knighthood" was "an alderman", was "Lord Mayor" two years ago, is "on the bench" (i.e. a magistrate), and "plays golf" with "our Chief Constable".
  • He is a self-made man, and personifies capitalism.
"We employers are coming together at last to see that our interests - and the interests of Capital - are properly protected
"A hardheaded* practical businessman" 
*notice the similarity to 'hard-hearted'. Birling often describes hismself, proudly, as "hard
"a man has to make his own way"*
*i.e. expect no help from anyone else 
  • His factory is important in the town. But less important than that of Gerald Croft's father, of "Crofts Limited".
  • Birling thinks that because he's successful in business, this puts him in a position to judge what's correct (Titanic, Germany) - which is why, for him, the arrival of the Inspector is so traumatic.
"…I’m talking as a hard-headed, practical man of
business. And I say there isn’t a chance of war.
"

Birling's first reaction to the Inspector
1. he tries to get him on side - with offers of 'port', and mention that the Chief Constable is a personal friend - this is almost an attempt at intimidation;
2. he challenges and rejects his authority.
"I don't like that tone"
"I can't accept any responsibility. If we were all responsible for everything that happened to everybody ... it would be very awkward*, wouldn't it?
*note the understatement - 'awkward' suggest mere embarrassment. The girl has "died in agony". This is litotes and is ironic.

3. Birling’s main concern is that his reputation and future social advancement will be damaged. On hearing of the death of Eva Smith, he cannot see that his actions in firing her had any consequences:
"Look - there’s nothing mysterious – or scandalous –  about this as far as I’m concerned.  Obviously it has  nothing to do with the wretched girl’s suicide."
He feels entirely justified by purely mercenary belief in "lower costs and higher profits" that does not weigh the human cost. Even towards the end, where he feels guilty, he still measures in money: "Look Inspector – I’d give thousands."

The Inspector does not blame Mr Birling entirely but he reminds him that he "started it".

Birling's Relationship with Eric
"You damned fool - why didn't you come to me?"
Eric replies: "you're not the kind of father a chap could go to when he’s in trouble"
Birling: "you've been spoilt" "you're the one I blame for this"

Does Birling learn his lesson?
His first reaction, when the Inspector exits is 1. to blame Eric 2. to say there will be "a public scandal" and complain about his chance of a "knighthood" underlining his essential selfishness, and belief (as Sheila said, critically) that it's "every man for himself".

He says "there's every excuse for what your mother and I did", "nothing much has happened" though he claims "I've learnt plenty tonight"

After the phone calls to the hospital and the police station, which seem to prove Goole is a hoax, Birling becomes [rather excited].  He mocks his son and daughter who have taken the Inspector’s warning about everyone having responsibility for each other seriously:
"the famous younger generation who know it all. And they can’t even take a joke"
Birling represents the type of greedy and ambitious businessman who builds his fortunes at the expense of everyone else.  He lacks the humanity that makes us aware of the needs of other and our impact on them and Priestley’s ending suggests that he believes he ought to suffer for this.